Concept

Over Renovating

What it is

Over renovating is spending more on a rehab than the neighborhood will pay you back for. Every street has a ceiling. It’s the top of the range of comps — the price buyers in that market are willing to reach for. Put quartz countertops, custom tile, and designer lighting in a house where every comp topped out on laminate and LVP, and you’ve just spent money the appraisal won’t support and the buyer won’t pay for.

Most of it comes from treating a flip like a personal project. You start picking finishes you’d want in your own house. You add a feature the previous house didn’t have. You say yes to “while we’re in there.” Each decision looks small. Stacked together, they push the all-in cost past the comp ceiling and your profit evaporates.

Why it matters

I had this one. I’m going to be totally honest about it.

In Denver, I bought a house, took the roof off, built a second story, built a three-car garage in the back. I was going to sell it for around $800,000. I ran up every credit card. I cleared out every red cent I had. Asked my lender for more money and then more money and then more money. Got every amount of credit from stores to buy appliances. Just to get to the end of the project.

While I was finishing that thing — this prison sentence — the dude across the street bought a house and did a basic flip. Basic cosmetic work. Made a six-figure profit, done in months. I’m sitting there losing money. I finally sold mine for $667,500. Not $800,000. And the guy who bought it from me gave me a dead fish handshake. Wouldn’t even look me in the eyes. He knew my back was against the wall. I owed all these people money and I just had to take it. That was the worst experience of my life. I almost quit real estate at that point.

The lesson: a neighborhood can only support so much. The other houses in that neighborhood weren’t selling for $800,000. They didn’t have the roof torn off, a second story, a three-car garage. What was I doing? That house didn’t belong there. It could only sell for the max amount in that neighborhood. Don’t over renovate. Only renovate to the neighborhood.

How it shows up

The tell is scope creep mid-project. You swapped laminate for LVP — fine. But then LVP made the old trim look bad, so you replaced the trim. New trim made the walls look bad, so now you’re skim-coating. That’s give a mouse a cookie in action, and it ends in an over-renovated house. Set your scope against the baseline of your comps, and have the discipline to stop.

The designer upgrade version: tile backsplash instead of paint. Soft-close drawers on rental cabinets. A farmhouse sink in a B-class flip. Each upgrade is a line item your appraisal will not reward. On a flip, you don’t get paid for finishes above the range. On a rental, tenants destroy upgrades that landlord-grade finishes would have survived.

The fix is mechanical. Pull three comps, match their finish level, and walk away from anything above it. Write the scope to hit the baseline and invest only where the big three demand it. Everything else is money you’re setting on fire.

range of comps, baseline, big three, hgtv dilemma, give a mouse a cookie, new builder itis, base hits